Dow
Jones
8,385.85
-57.05
9:30
am PST, January 22, 2003
NASDAQ
1,371.95
+7.70
For
info, visit access.smallcapnetwork.com
S
& P 500
885.11
-2.52
To
be removed, please click
here
Russell
2000
381.97
-1.20
VOLUME
02: ISSUE 91
Putting ATI in its place.
From the folks at the Ontario Securities
Commission, who are still grappling, years later, with investigations into
Bre-X, Livent and YBM Magnex, comes another name to add to the list: ATI
Technologies Inc.
So the story goes, back in early
2000, a small number of insiders allegedly bought put options in offshore
accounts-which is like a limited risk short sale-to profit from a decline
in the company's share price. Some others allegedly sold shares to miss
the decline or gave shares to charity for a snappy tax break; all prior
to the release of a May 24th 2000 warning of crummy third quarter numbers.
Allegations all, and given that the
company has been pounded down to $4.50-a level not seen since the first
quarter of 2001-one has to step back and wonder if there is an opportunity
here. Although the hearing for all this is slated for Valentines Day, don't
look for resolution anytime soon.
And this matters to...?
The poster CEO in all this is KY
Ho, the man who brought his moxie and contacts to form the company in 1985
and took it public in 1993. In a seeming fight to the death, the company
has seen its past fortunes decline at the hands of competitor Nvidia (NVDA:
NASDAQ) --as well as a more than soft demand for its products.
Unlike other corporate shenanigans,
these allegations concerning ATI appear to be limited to a small group
of individuals-less than ten-- who may have used insider information for
personal profit, rather than looting the company as was the case with Enron
or Tyco. The numbers-less than $10 million-- are small in the whole scheme
of things and if the allegations are proven there will likely be fines,
recriminations and disgorgement of trading profits.
Will it destroy ATI? Probably not.
Caveat emptor... at least for a
while.
To run out and buy ATI now would
likely be folly until the facts are better known. That being said though,
there are two caveats. The first is that the allegations, while a knife
in the company's side, are likely no more than a flesh wound. The folks
at the center of this investigation, if found to be at fault, were more
about insider opportunity than $6000 shower curtains. If there was a conspiracy,
it hasn't, as yet, hit any vital organs. The other is that this regulatory
exercise may well take years to sort out. Regulators, although newly emboldened
in the current environment, still move in baby steps and right now all
we have are sensational allegations; substance, if any, will be a while
coming.
The concluding scene in this melodrama
will likely have little or no effect on ATI as a whole short of some potential
management changes, shuffles or nothing at all if no wrongdoing is found.
Some of those named have already left the company and others were spouses
of employees. In the interim, it is better to look at ATI and perhaps NVidia
as players in a sector that still seems stalled.
Even if this firestorm hadn't hit
ATI, to purchase now would have been a speculation on a turnaround for
the sector. It still is. There are two types of corporate malfeasance:
criminal and just plain stupid. I leave it to you to decide which this
is if proven.
Slam-dunk? No. Lay-up maybe...
First Call has projections for ATI
of 17 cents for this fiscal year (as at August 31) and 34 cents for 2004.
With the shares at $4.50, these numbers are somewhat compelling. The event
risk of the OSC (or possibly the SEC) throwing a wider investigative net,
deepening the malfeasance won't help the shares if that eventuality comes
to pass.
ATI routinely now posts, annually,
over a billion dollars in revenue and reported $322 million in the first
quarter of 2003, up 34 percent sequentially and 29 percent against the
first quarter 2002. The company has given guidance that its second quarter
revenues should be roughly 10 percent lower than its first. Take the regulatory
clouds away and a punt sub-$5 a share has an air of potential about it.
Market perils aren't exclusive
to any one stock.
Any stock purchase these days is
fraught with potential peril, be it the possibility of corporate wrongdoing,
wars in foreign lands or the ever-present socioeconomic and geopolitical
market risks. What investors must do-no matter what the company-- is investigate
situations as they arise and decide if they affect the big picture. So
far, at least with ATI and its future, a turnaround in capital spending
should be of more interest to investors than allegations of personal wrongdoing.
Could ATI and its ilk go lower? Sure
they could. Is there an investment/trading opportunity now that this investigation
is out in the open? Perhaps. Those speculators who live for these sorts
of situations-stocks pounded by somewhat extraneous events-might just profit
from a sector or market snapback and strap on a relatively good company
to boot.
Nobody said investing was easy-or
logical.
Nb... in a recent piece it was
noted-- (due to a slipped keystroke--) that the Dow peaked at 15,000. More
like 11,760. The writer has been flogged. Thanks for the emails....
D I S C
L A I M E R :
The
SmallCap Digest is an independent electronic publication committed to providing
our readers with factual information on selected publicly traded
companies. SmallCap Digest is not a registered investment advisor or broker-dealer.
All companies are chosen on the basis of certain financial analysis and
other pertinent criteria with a view toward maximizing the upside
potential for investors while minimizing the downside risk, whenever possible.
Moreover, as detailed below, this publication accepts compensation from
third party consultants and/or companies which it features for the publication
and circulation of the SmallCap Digest or representation on SmallCapNetwork.net.
Likewise, this newsletter is owned by TGR, LLC. To the degrees enumerated
herein, this newsletter should not be regarded as an independent
publication.
Click
Here to view our compensation on every company we have ever covered,
or visit the following web address: http://access.smallcapnetwork.com/compensation_disclosure.html
for our full compensation disclosure and http://access.smallcapnetwork.com/short_term_alerts.html
for Trading Alerts compensation and disclosure. TGR Group LLC has not been
compensated for this report.
All statements
and expressions are the sole opinions of the editors and are subject
to change without notice. A profile, description, or other mention of a
company in the newsletter is neither an offer nor solicitation to buy or
sell any securities mentioned. While we believe all sources of information
to be factual and reliable, in no way do we represent or guarantee the
accuracy thereof, nor the statements made herein.
The editor,
members of the editor's family, and/or entities with which the editor
is affiliated, are forbidden by company policy to own, buy, sell or otherwise
trade stock for their own benefit in the companies who appear in the publication.
The profiles, critiques, and other editorial content of the SmallCap Digest
and SmallCapNetwork.net may contain forward-looking statements relating
to the expected capabilities of the companies mentioned herein.
THE READER
SHOULD VERIFY ALL CLAIMS AND DO THEIR OWN DUE DILIGENCE BEFORE INVESTING
IN ANY SECURITIES MENTIONED. INVESTING IN SECURITIES IS SPECULATIVE
AND CARRIES A HIGH DEGREE OF RISK. THE INFORMATION FOUND IN THIS PROFILE
IS PROTECTED BY THE COPYRIGHT LAWS OF THE UNITED STATES AND MAY NOT BE
COPIED, OR REPRODUCED IN ANY WAY WITHOUT THE EXPRESSED, WRITTEN CONSENT
OF THE EDITORS OF SMALLCAPNETWORK.NET.
We encourage
our readers to invest carefully and read the investor information available
at the web sites of the Securities and Exchange Commission ("SEC")
at http://www.sec.gov and/or the National
Association of Securities Dealers ("NASD") at http://www.nasd.com.
We also strongly recommend that you read the SEC advisory to investors
concerning Internet Stock Fraud, which can be found at http://www.sec.gov/consumer/cyberfr.htm
. Readers can review all public filings by companies at the SEC's EDGAR
page. The NASD has published information on how to invest carefully at
its web site.