Dow
Jones
10139.71
+10.47
1:00
pm PST, July 30, 2004
NASDAQ
1887.36
+6.30
For
info, visit access.smallcapnetwork.com
S
& P 500
1101.71
+1.28
To
be removed, please click
here
Russell
2000
550.93
+1.10
VOLUME
04: ISSUE 59
Feature:
Insider selling. Rarely a big deal.
"Great company, but what about all the
insider selling?" is a relatively common refrain populating my email box.
Relax. Insiders are people too.
By definition, SmallCap companies
don't have a lot of dough. To attract the best people, company stock and/or
options--usually the stock is restricted from sale for at least a year--
are routinely offered or given to round out a compensation package. In
some cases, especially in companies in their formative stages, the officers
and directors may take virtually no cash compensation and instead receive
stock in lieu. As well, people that have acquired shares from the company
for financing or other corporate services need to sell, eventually.
Are these folks who have taken a
significant personal financial risk supposed to never sell?
Give yourself a shake.
Here's some fodder for thought: Bill
Gates sells the maximum stock he is allowed every quarter and has done
so for years and years. Does that mean he is concerned about Mister Softee's
future? Ah, no.
To ensure that massive amounts of
insider, or control (ownership of greater than 10 percent of the issued
stock) stock, doesn't hit the market willy-nilly, there is the ubiquitous--some
wags would say infamous--Rule 144.
Taking stock in the SEC
Insider and control stock is, in
the majority, restricted from sale when acquired directly from a company
or it's affiliate. We'll get into that in a moment, as well as other conditions
necessary for sale under Rule 144. The good folks at the Securities and
Exchange Commission state:
"Investors typically receive restricted
securities through private placement offerings, Regulation D offerings,
employee stock benefit plans, as compensation for professional services,
or in exchange for providing "seed money" or start-up capital to the company."
"Control means the power to
direct the management and policies of the company in question, whether
through the ownership of voting securities, by contract, or otherwise."
Although we'll merely hit the
highlights on insider selling, you'll want to read the definitive SEC rules
here: http://www.sec.gov/answers/rule144.htm
.
To be able to sell previously restricted
shares, a number of conditions must be present to ensure both fairness
as well as minimal impact on the market.
Rules, Rules, Rules.
Before one sells or seeks an exemption
to sell restricted investor stock, the seller must file a form 144, but
only after the following points have been satisfied:
The shares in question must have been
held for at least one year.
After the one-year holding period, the
number of shares you may sell during any three-month period can't exceed
the greater of 1% of the outstanding shares of the same class being sold,
or if the class is listed on a stock exchange or quoted on NASDAQ, the
greater of 1% or the average reported weekly trading volume during the
four weeks preceding the filing a notice of the sale on Form 144. Over-the-counter
stocks, including those quoted on the OTC Bulletin Board and the Pink Sheets,
can only be sold using the 1% measurement.
The company's SEC corporate filings
must be up to date.
Normal commissions need be paid.
At the time you place your order, you
must file a notice with the SEC on Form 144 if the sale involves more than
500 shares or the aggregate dollar amount is greater than $10,000 in any
three-month period. The sale must take place within three months of filing
the Form and, if the securities have not been sold, you must file an amended
notice.
Once the restriction has been lifted,
the seller must get the "restricted" legend removed from the share certificate.
Once the eventual sale transaction is
completed, a Form 4 must be filed with relevant detail.
The above only applies to stock received
from a company or affiliate for the reasons noted. Purchases made by affiliates
or control groups in the open market do not require the full Rule 144 treatment--specifically
the holding period. The other conditions for sale do apply. As far as stock
options are concerned, the restriction timer kicks in once the options
have been exercised and not the date they were granted.
Once a Form 144 has been filed and
accepted--which can take 2-4 weeks, the seller has 90 days to sell or must
file an amendment should that period lapse.
Filing and refilling a Form
144 is standard practice, especially with SmallCaps. One may well look
at the Insider Transaction section on Yahoo and seem a bunch of entries
called 'Planned Sales".
That characterization doesn't mean
the shares have been sold--there's not even any hint as to whether they
will be or not. The time-consuming practice of freeing up restricted stock
is merely to allow those who need to file a Form 144 the flexibility to
sell in the future should they so choose.
The roof is leaking...
So, if the director or officer et
al of a SmallCap company finds he/she needs a new roof, tuition for a child
or a new car and doesn't make the cash through salary, he/she can ensure
shares that have met the SEC criteria are available for sale by filing
a Form 144. Like the rest of us, he/she may want the ability to sell at
hand rather than have to wait the standard 2-4 weeks for approval, especially
if there is a critical personal situation.
In a lot of cases, an insider will
file a Form 144 to have a restriction removed so that the shares can be
used as collateral to buy more shares.
Most companies will go the extra
step of ensuring by company policy that the timing of a sale by insider
or related parties doesn't occur around or prior to the announcement of
earnings or other material events. There is usually--or should be--an attorney
or compliance officer's blessing prior to either purchase or sale both
for legal reasons and transparency to shareholders.
Sure, we'd like to see lots of insider
purchases within the stocks we own. But be confident that for the vast,
vast majority of insiders and affected others, the SEC rules ensure that
sales will be fair, open and transparent to the other shareholders and
the marketplace.
The time to be concerned is if you
see an insider list where the appropriate parties have filed to sell all
or large portions of their shares.
Otherwise, don't be too quick to
condemn. The reasons for sale, I would submit are, for the most part, likely
more mundane and personal than any material or editorial comment on the
company's prospects.
We
Value Your Feedback
Got comments, questions or suggestions?
Send 'em on over:
Editor@smallcapnetwork.com
If you wish to send a written request
or inquiry, please send it to our physical address:
TGR Group, LLC
3525 Del Mar Heights Rd #334
San Diego, CA 92130
Unsubscribe
Here
D I S C
L A I M E R :
The
SmallCap Digest is an independent electronic publication committed to providing
our readers with factual information on selected publicly traded
companies. SmallCap Digest is not a registered investment advisor or broker-dealer.
All companies are chosen on the basis of certain financial analysis and
other pertinent criteria with a view toward maximizing the upside
potential for investors while minimizing the downside risk, whenever possible.
Moreover, as detailed below, this publication accepts compensation from
third party consultants and/or companies which it features for the publication
and circulation of the SmallCap Digest or representation on SmallCapNetwork.net.
Likewise, this newsletter is owned by TGR, LLC. To the degrees enumerated
herein, this newsletter should not be regarded as an independent
publication.
Click
Here to view our compensation on every company we have ever covered,
or visit the following web address: http://access.smallcapnetwork.com/compensation_disclosure.html
for our full compensation disclosure and http://access.smallcapnetwork.com/short_term_alerts.html
for Trading Alerts compensation and disclosure. TGR Group LLC has not been
compensated for this report.
All statements
and expressions are the sole opinions of the editors and are subject
to change without notice. A profile, description, or other mention of a
company in the newsletter is neither an offer nor solicitation to buy or
sell any securities mentioned. While we believe all sources of information
to be factual and reliable, in no way do we represent or guarantee the
accuracy thereof, nor the statements made herein.
The editor,
members of the editor's family, and/or entities with which the editor
is affiliated, are forbidden by company policy to own, buy, sell or otherwise
trade stock for their own benefit in the companies who appear in the publication
unless specifically disclosed in the newsletter. The profiles, critiques,
and other editorial content of the SmallCap Digest and SmallCapNetwork.net
may contain forward-looking statements relating to the expected capabilities
of the companies mentioned herein.
THE READER
SHOULD VERIFY ALL CLAIMS AND DO THEIR OWN DUE DILIGENCE BEFORE INVESTING
IN ANY SECURITIES MENTIONED. INVESTING IN SECURITIES IS SPECULATIVE
AND CARRIES A HIGH DEGREE OF RISK. THE INFORMATION FOUND IN THIS PROFILE
IS PROTECTED BY THE COPYRIGHT LAWS OF THE UNITED STATES AND MAY NOT BE
COPIED, OR REPRODUCED IN ANY WAY WITHOUT THE EXPRESSED, WRITTEN CONSENT
OF THE EDITORS OF SMALLCAPNETWORK.NET.
We encourage
our readers to invest carefully and read the investor information available
at the web sites of the Securities and Exchange Commission ("SEC")
at http://www.sec.gov and/or the National
Association of Securities Dealers ("NASD") at http://www.nasd.com.
We also strongly recommend that you read the SEC advisory to investors
concerning Internet Stock Fraud, which can be found at http://www.sec.gov/consumer/cyberfr.htm
. Readers can review all public filings by companies at the SEC's EDGAR
page. The NASD has published information on how to invest carefully at
its web site.