Dow
Jones
9114.06
+63.24
10:20
am PST, July 18, 2003
NASDAQ
1699.67
+1.65
For
info, visit access.smallcapnetwork.com
S
& P 500
986.04
+4.31
To
be removed, please click
here
Russell
2000
462.26
+2.33
VOLUME
03: ISSUE 38
Broker
or Client: Who's the Boss?
Lots of mail on our piece How
to Find a Good Broker. A couple of caveats: we have nothing against
Merrill Lynch, and this series is for investors who need help with their
'safe' money. For those who are adept in the small cap arena, we would
strongly suggest you consider a discount or online broker for those trades.
No sense in paying a full service advisor and paying for information you
don't need or want.
That said, as the market improves,
you might decide to seek out some of the broad range of services a traditional
broker may provide. There's no reason that you can't have two accounts--one
for your core portfolio and one for those nifty ideas you unearth for yourself.
At the conclusion of our last article,
we were about to interview brokers recommended by a full service investment
dealer's office manager.
Some
general rules of engagement:
If, at any time, you're not comfortable,
or find that the advisor is at odds with your investment philosophy, walk.
As we've said, there are too many good, competent brokers out there to
settle for second best.
Make notes. Become familiar with the
firm and, by extension, the advisor's policies. Learn about charges, timelines
and possible pitfalls.
View the advisor as your employee. Too
many investors are intimidated by the 'broker aura'. Don't be. Advisors
need your business more than you need them.
Get references of some of his/her clients
in situations similar to yours.
Establish a commission discount policy
for your trades, if appropriate.
Understand how your orders will be executed
and confirmed and whether the advisor uses stop losses.
Does s(he) listen.
The preceding may seem obvious,
but it's amazing how people throw money--sometimes millions of dollars--
at brokers with little or no due diligence. Money and sex are the two most
difficult things to talk about. Get over it. And I guarantee that you won't
have to talk about sex with a broker. Unless you want to. In which case,
you're on your own.
I
ask, therefore I'll know.
The most important thing you can
discern from an advisor is his/her trading philosophy. Brokers work on
the principle of the 'velocity' of money. If their 'book' isn't turning
over, they don't make money. There is a quick ratio you can get--or should--
from a broker. It goes by many names including 'style ratio'. This indicator
is derived from dividing annual commissions by the size of the advisor's
client asset book.
For example: if an advisor oversees
client assets of $25 million and consistently generates commissions of
$250,000, the style ratio is 1 percent. This connotes an advisor who has
a low turnover and likely holds stocks or other assets for clients on a
long-term basis. If that same broker generates $1 million of commissions
on the same book of business, the style ratio is 4 percent and likely trades
frequently. If the number is over about 1.5 percent, unless you plan to
be a heavy trader, look elsewhere.
A high style ratio doesn't necessarily
mean the broker is a churner--one who trades clients too often merely to
generate commission. The ratio may merely be a reflection of the advisor's
clientele, which may be comprised, of frequent traders. If that's not for
you, move on. Brokers may be hesitant to give out their style ratio, but
best to insist. And not just for one year. A style ratio over a number
of years will give you a snapshot of who you're dealing with. While not
definitive, it could save you a lot of time. As a matter of fact, you should
be able to get the number from the manager. You might want to even take
the initiative and make one of your conditions that the advisors recommended
have low style ratios.
As I said, the ratio goes by many
names, but the math is easy and very telling. I have known brokers with
ratios from below one to all the way into the double digits.
Like
me, like my philosophy.
It seems obvious to find an advisor
that shares your investment philosophy and risk orientation. Ask them what
types of investments they make for their own accounts. Do they buy the
same investments they recommend for clients? Do they invest in the market
at all? A broker who is too heavily in the market might be distracted,
while one who only invests in say, antique Chinese snuff bottles, may be
out of touch.
Most important is to discuss contact.
How often can you expect to be contacted? How accessible is the advisor?
If you're going to end up speaking almost exclusively to an assistant,
perhaps you should interview the assistant. Structure a contact system
that you can both live with. Also, meet the assistant, as s (he) will be
your administrative contact. Don't waste your time, or the advisor's, with
account details. The times when the two of you speak should be used for
strategy, portfolio construction and decisions.
Want
a friend? Get a dog.
In conclusion, you don't have to
like the individual broker you choose, but it helps. Don't use a relative,
friend or brother-in-law. This is serious business and if there are problems,
you don't want to be in the uncomfortable position of being across a Thanksgiving
turkey. Keep the two aspects of your life separate.
Now
that you have conducted your interviews, go home, speak to friends and
peers and wait a few days to make a decision. Review your notes and don't
be afraid to call any of the players with questions or concerns. The better
the due diligence, the less likelihood that there will be unpleasantness
down the road. And you will have established yourself in the eyes of the
firm as a serious, prepared investor.
Any good relationship takes work.
Make sure it's on your terms. You are the client and it's your money.
Make sure no one ever forgets that.
Got questions or comments? Send 'em
here: editor@smallcapnetwork.com
Unsubscribe
Here
D I S C
L A I M E R :
The
SmallCap Digest is an independent electronic publication committed to providing
our readers with factual information on selected publicly traded
companies. SmallCap Digest is not a registered investment advisor or broker-dealer.
All companies are chosen on the basis of certain financial analysis and
other pertinent criteria with a view toward maximizing the upside
potential for investors while minimizing the downside risk, whenever possible.
Moreover, as detailed below, this publication accepts compensation from
third party consultants and/or companies which it features for the publication
and circulation of the SmallCap Digest or representation on SmallCapNetwork.net.
Likewise, this newsletter is owned by TGR, LLC. To the degrees enumerated
herein, this newsletter should not be regarded as an independent
publication.
Click
Here to view our compensation on every company we have ever covered,
or visit the following web address: http://access.smallcapnetwork.com/compensation_disclosure.html
for our full compensation disclosure and http://access.smallcapnetwork.com/short_term_alerts.html
for Trading Alerts compensation and disclosure. TGR Group, LLC has not
been compensated for this report.
All statements
and expressions are the sole opinions of the editors and are subject
to change without notice. A profile, description, or other mention of a
company in the newsletter is neither an offer nor solicitation to buy or
sell any securities mentioned. While we believe all sources of information
to be factual and reliable, in no way do we represent or guarantee the
accuracy thereof, nor the statements made herein.
The editor,
members of the editor's family, and/or entities with which the editor
is affiliated, are forbidden by company policy to own, buy, sell or otherwise
trade stock for their own benefit in the companies who appear in the publication
unless specifically disclosed in the newsletter. The profiles, critiques,
and other editorial content of the SmallCap Digest and SmallCapNetwork.net
may contain forward-looking statements relating to the expected capabilities
of the companies mentioned herein.
THE READER
SHOULD VERIFY ALL CLAIMS AND DO THEIR OWN DUE DILIGENCE BEFORE INVESTING
IN ANY SECURITIES MENTIONED. INVESTING IN SECURITIES IS SPECULATIVE
AND CARRIES A HIGH DEGREE OF RISK. THE INFORMATION FOUND IN THIS PROFILE
IS PROTECTED BY THE COPYRIGHT LAWS OF THE UNITED STATES AND MAY NOT BE
COPIED, OR REPRODUCED IN ANY WAY WITHOUT THE EXPRESSED, WRITTEN CONSENT
OF THE EDITORS OF SMALLCAPNETWORK.NET.
We encourage
our readers to invest carefully and read the investor information available
at the web sites of the Securities and Exchange Commission ("SEC")
at http://www.sec.gov and/or the National
Association of Securities Dealers ("NASD") at http://www.nasd.com.
We also strongly recommend that you read the SEC advisory to investors
concerning Internet Stock Fraud, which can be found at http://www.sec.gov/consumer/cyberfr.htm
. Readers can review all public filings by companies at the SEC's EDGAR
page. The NASD has published information on how to invest carefully at
its web site.