The
Upside of the Market's Bearish Mondays
You
know what might be the best thing for the stock market today? A big
fat dip. Seriously.
No,
I haven't flipped out ... at least not yet anyway. I was just reviewing
some market-related things this weekend, and was reminded of something
I mentioned in mid-October that I somehow put on the shelf since then.
In short, Monday's
have been a habitually rough day for the overall stock market over
the course of the last several weeks.
As
of October 19th, six of the prior eight Mondays had been bearish; four
of them were downright disastrous. Since October 19th, five out of
seven Mondays have been bearish, with one of them being disastrous. Granted,
we're in a bear market so we're bound to get more bearish days than bullish
days. Statistically speaking though, we've seen more than a fair share
of losses specifically on Mondays. (All the Mondays on the nearby chart
of the S&P 500 have been marked with a red arrow.)
But
don't we have a bullish trade on? Why would we want to see a pullback?
That's
a fair question, and here's my honest answer ... I don't mind taking
one step back in order to take two steps forward. My only goal is to
buy low and sell how, and if that's what the market gives me, then I'll
take it. The two-steps-forward and one-step-backwards pattern isn't
sexy, but if it works, then it works. It's sustainable.
What's
not
sustainable (and what worries me) is three or four really
good - consecutive -days for stocks. We saw it happen in late October,
and again in late November. Both times though, the market paid the price
for providing too much profit-taking potential.
The
last four trading days haven't been exactly "wildly bullish", but the three
winning days and one losing day - after Monday's debacle - still
sent the S&P 500 up by 7.3%. That may well be pushing the limits
of sustainability. So, perhaps a slight cooling may actually be a healthy
thing. Given our recent history with Mondays, maybe today's the
day it makes the most sense to give a little ground ... to bleed off any
unhealthy euphoria.
In
other words, a rough day today isn't a bearish omen.
On
that note, I think it merits being explicit about this ... I'm not saying
today will be bearish - I'm just pointing out the odds and pattern.
What I am saying, however, is the bulls need to control their
pace at this delicate time. This really could be the beginning of at
least a near-term move higher, but moderation is the key. A slight
'give' sometime this week, followed by a recovery, could be just the ticket.
The
Chart's Bigger Picture
Monday
tendencies not withstanding, there are some other things on the
chart worth a look.
As
much as I'm a fan of strong fundamentals, to be honest, I get at least
as
much good information from charts. See, just because a company's books
look solid doesn't mean its stock always moves higher. It should,
but it doesn't. At least with a chart I have a reasonable idea about
what the odds of a rise or fall may be. Obviously the 'read' isn't
always
right, but neither is the assumption that great companies always make for
great stocks.
With
this in mind, I wanted to point out a couple of bullish aspects of the
S&P 500's chart, as well as highlight something that's almost bullish,
despite
knowing fundamentals are still ugly right now.
As
simple as moving averages are, they're still powerful tools. Personally,
I think their power comes from their simplicity. More importantly
though, I use them as indicators because they tend to work better than
not.
Anyway,
you
may want to note the S&P 500 crawled back above its 20 day moving average
line (green, entwined with the S&P 500) on Friday. That's
not a significantly big deal - we've seen it happen two other times
since late September, and both of those times ended up being nothing
more than set-ups for more selling. However, the slope of the lines' descent
is shallowing, and this move back above the 20 day line came considerably
easier than the last one did. That's a hint the selling pressure is dissipating.
(And yes, a weak Monday will indeed mean the market slips back under
the 20 day line temporarily.)
Similarly,
the VIX finally appears willing to back off of recent all-time highs.
I can't get into a discussion right now about why the VIX is so important
- there's not enough time or room. If
you're interested though, click here to go to a detailed take. For
now, let's just say a falling VIX is good for stocks, and a rising VIX
is bad for stocks .... an over-simplified but effective explanation.
Anyway,
though the VIX has inched lower the last few days, I have to wonder if
the lower Bollinger band (blue) is yet-again going to be a reversal
point. If so, then this brief burst of bullishness is doomed. If
instead the VIX brushes the lower band, and then just keeps gently pushing
it lower, then stocks have a real shot at sustaining a rally.
And
there's that word again ... sustainability, which segues nicely
into my third and final observation about this chart.
One
of my commonly cited reasons for a lack of sustainability for any of the
market's recent rallies was simply the lack of buyers behind the effort.
There
have to be more buyers than sellers for the market to rise, and it can't
just be a one-day effort ... there have to be more buyers than sellers
over a measurable period of time to get the market out of its rut.
We've had neither of those things for a while now - and the market
has accordingly gone nowhere.
However,
the volume tide may finally be turning. Take a look at the volume bars
right under the VIX - there are more green bullish bars than red bearish
bars, and those green volume bars are a little taller than they were in
October and November. It's still not what I would call ideal fore the bulls
yet; those green bars should be gradually rising as time passes.
But, it's getting better.
At
the bottom of the chart I've added one of my favorite volume tools - an
accumulation-distribution line (the lone green line). It's basically
showing the same information the volume bars are showing me, but I like
the A-D line's simplicity ...rising is bullish, and falling is bearish.
The
point today is simply this - things really are at least a little
different with this move than they were with similar rallies over the prior
two months. We're not out of the woods yet, but this is our best shot so
far.